Dairy-free doesn’t mean ice cream free! This creamy dairy-free vanilla ice cream includes all of the same wonderful flavors and textures of traditional ice cream. See if your guests can tell the difference!
June 25 2020 recipe by Kristie Sullivan, PhD, photo by Naomi Sherman, nutritional review by Franziska Spritzler, RD, CDE in Recipes, Dessert
Dairy-free doesn’t mean ice cream free! This creamy dairy-free vanilla ice cream includes all of the same wonderful flavors and textures of traditional ice cream. See if your guests can tell the difference!
USMetric
6 servingservings
Ingredients
Dairy-free vanilla ice cream
- 6 6 large egg yolkslarge eggs yolks
- 1 cup 240 ml coconut milk
- 1¼ cups 300 ml unsweetened almond milk
- 1⁄3 cup (2½ oz.) 80 ml (70 g) xylitol
- 1⁄3 cup 80 ml mild flavored avocado oil
- 2 tsp 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 1⁄8 tsp 1⁄8 tsp salt (optional)
This recipe has been added to the shopping list.
www.dietdoctor.com
Making low carb simple
Instructions
Instructions are for 6 servings. Please modify as needed.
Ice cream
In a heavy saucepan over low heat, heat the coconut milk and almond milk, stirring with a whisk. Add the egg yolks. Continue whisking on low heat until the custard begins to thicken.
Add the sweetener and whisk until completely dissolved. Continue heating, whisking constantly, until the custard thickens, about 10 minutes.
When the custard coats the back of a wooden spoon or reaches 140°F (60°C) on a thermometer, remove the pan from the heat. Do not allow the mixture to warm to over 140°F (60°C) or the eggs will begin to cook.
Add the oil, vanilla, salt, and mix together carefully in a blender, or with an immersion blender. Allow the mixture to cool in the refrigerator.
When the mixture is cool, freeze in an ice cream maker following the manufacturer’s directions. Continue processing the ice cream until it is frozen or reaches your desired consistency. Store in the freezer.
You might also like
- ★4.99|5 m|EasyWhipped dairy-free low carb (Dalgona) coffee
- ★4.89|75 m|EasyKeto seed crackers
- ★4.72|70 m|MediumThe keto bread
- ★5.00|2 m|EasyChipotle mayonnaise
- ★5.00|25 m|EasyRoasted tomato salad
- ★5.00|10 m|EasySatay sauce
- ★4.94|5 m|EasyRanch seasoning
- ★4.92|25 m|EasyFresh creamed spinach
- ★5.00|5 m|EasyFlavored water
- ★5.00|40 m|EasyLow carb chocolate peppermint cheesecake mousse
- ★5.00|20 m|EasyHerb butter
- ★4.78|45 m|MediumKeto Fathead pizza
- ★5.00|30 m|EasyRoasted spring vegetables with eggs and browned butter
- ★5.00|210 m|EasyLow carb vanilla panna cotta with strawberry rhubarb sauce
- ★5.00|10 m|EasyParmesan butter
- ★4.88|10 m|EasyGreek salad
- ★5.00|15 m|EasyKeto thousand island dressing
- ★4.88|5 m|EasyTex-Mex seasoning
- ★4.88|60 m|EasyLow carb sesame crispbread
- ★5.00|320 m|MediumHomemade chicken stock
- ★5.00|30 m|EasyRoasted pumpkin with nuts and manchego cheese
- ★4.56|110 m|ChallengingLow carb lamb roast with broccoli purée
- ★4.96|40 m|EasyPork shoulder chops with cauliflower au gratin
- ★4.81|30 m|EasyKeto Asian cabbage stir-fry
- ★4.78|40 m|EasyThai chicken with satay sauce and broccoli
- ★4.93|40 m|EasyItalian chicken meatballs with cream sauce and broccoli
- ★4.86|50 m|MediumLow carb Zoodles Bolognese
- ★4.96|30 m|EasyKeto lamb sliders with feta cheese dressing
- ★4.86|30 m|EasyKeto stuffed mushrooms
- ★4.87|45 m|EasyKeto pesto chicken casserole with feta cheese and olives
←
→
DD+ MEMBERSHIP
Want to lose weight and improve your health? Try a ketogenic (keto), low-carb,or high-protein diet. Stay on track by following our nutritionally reviewed meal plans.
Whether you’re looking for high-protein, strict keto, or liberal low-carb recipes, here you’ll find tons of tasty recipes to choose from. Discover our wide range of healthy recipes.
There are many thoughts and ideas about what foods are and aren’t part of a healthy diet. Learn more about what foods you can expect from our recipes.
💬 Have you tried this recipe?
What did you think? Please share your thoughts in the comment section below!
19 comments
1
Jay
June 30 2020
Could I use Coconut Oil instead of Avocado Oil?
Reply: #2
2
Reply to comment #1 by Jay
Crystal Pullen Team Diet Doctor
June 30 2020
Could I use Coconut Oil instead of Avocado Oil?
I do no think coconut oil would work in ice cream. Extra light olive oil or avocado oil is best.
3
Robin
July 1 2020
I checked this recipe out because my youngest has come to live with us and she's dairy-free (poor kid - I would hate to live without dairy though I've been considering it as my weight loss has stalled somewhat).
I love you guys but I have a recommendation: any recipe that uses xylitol MUST include a warning in the tips that it is deadly to dogs so that pet owners are aware of the risk if they give their pets table scraps. Maybe to cats, too - I don't know for sure, but I do know it's deadly to dogs. I think it's great that you explained why it's used in this recipe, and how erythritol makes a difference. Please expand that to include whether Stevia or Monkfruit etc might or might not be a good option also? Thanks for providing so many dairy-free options on the site!!! :-)
Reply: #4
4
Reply to comment #3 by Robin
Kristin Parker Team Diet Doctor
July 1 2020
I checked this recipe out because my youngest has come to live with us and she's dairy-free (poor kid - I would hate to live without dairy though I've been considering it as my weight loss has stalled somewhat).
I love you guys but I have a recommendation: any recipe that uses xylitol MUST include a warning in the tips that it is deadly to dogs so that pet owners are aware of the risk if they give their pets table scraps. Maybe to cats, too - I don't know for sure, but I do know it's deadly to dogs. I think it's great that you explained why it's used in this recipe, and how erythritol makes a difference. Please expand that to include whether Stevia or Monkfruit etc might or might not be a good option also? Thanks for providing so many dairy-free options on the site!!! :-)Thank you for your feedback; the toxicity to dogs is mentioned in our sweetener guide but I understand not everyone will review that when following recipes. Other sweeteners will not keep the ice cream soft like xylitol does, with the exception of allulose which you can read about in this section of our guide.
https://www.dietdoctor.com/low-carb/keto/sweeteners#alluloseReply: #14
5
Derya
July 4 2020
Two words: Carrie Brown.
She’s the queen of keto ice-cream and the one who experimented with xylitol in the first place.
https://carriebrown.com/keto-ice-cream-scoop-cookbook
Or just visit her website or tune into her podcasts, she’s very entertaining, smart, and gives loads of tips beyond ice-cream.
6
Derya
July 4 2020
Quote from Carrie‘s website:
„Ice cream making is actually pretty complicated scientifically speaking – there’s a whole bunch of geekery around getting ice crystals to form the right way, not getting them to freeze too hard, or too soft, and other thrilling physics dilemmas to think about – and there are tons of little tips and tricks that will help you get that perfect scoop of KETO deliciousness every time. Sadly, one little recipe post won’t address most of that, but before you hop to the recipe please just cast your eye over this list. It’s a good place to start if you are new to the world of homemade ice cream, and since all of you are new to KETO ice cream, and KETO ice cream “custards” do not behave like regular ice cream custards, I urge you to pay attention. After waiting this long, I don’t want you to be disappointed with the result.“7
Derya
July 4 2020
Those of you with DOGS:
stick to ALLULOSE, which is birch-based and the next best thing to xylitol.
8
Ann Hough
July 5 2020
Even a small amount of xylitol will kill a dog. I won't have it in the house.
9
Beth Phelps
July 9 2020
Is the Coconut Milk in this recipe from a can? 1 cup of Coconut Milk that is mixed to incorporate the coconut cream that separates? Just need clarification. Thanks!
Reply: #10
10
Reply to comment #9 by Beth Phelps
Crystal Pullen Team Diet Doctor
July 9 2020
Is the Coconut Milk in this recipe from a can? 1 cup of Coconut Milk that is mixed to incorporate the coconut cream that separates? Just need clarification. Thanks!
Yes, a can of coconut milk with the contents mixed is best for this recipe.
11
Sandra Romero
August 17 2020
Is there a way to substitute eggs for a vegan version ?
Reply: #12
12
Reply to comment #11 by Sandra Romero
Kristin Parker Team Diet Doctor
August 18 2020
Is there a way to substitute eggs for a vegan version ?
I am not aware of a good substitute. You can omit them but the final texture and consistency may be icy and not very creamy.
13
Maria
September 12 2020
Chocolate is also lethal for dogs. But then I wouldn't give my dog ice cream or anything sweet anyhow.
14
Reply to comment #4 by Kristin Parker
Shirley
September 18 2020
Don't feed your pets table scraps.
15
Jane
November 26 2020
Can this recipe be completed in an ice cream maker?
Reply: #16
16
Reply to comment #15 by Jane
Crystal Pullen Team Diet Doctor
November 27 2020
Can this recipe be completed in an ice cream maker?
Yes, this recipe is appropriate for use in an ice cream maker. You will need to follow your manufacturer's instructions. I hope you enjoy it!
17
sdudley649
November 1 2021
Any suggestions on how to make ice cream without an ice cream maker?
Reply: #18
18
Reply to comment #17 by sdudley649
Kristin Parker Team Diet Doctor
November 1 2021
Any suggestions on how to make ice cream without an ice cream maker?
We have a mason jar ice cream recipe that can be adapted to different flavors.
https://www.dietdoctor.com/recipes/keto-mason-jar-ice-cream19
Gloria
February 2 2022
I had a really hard time getting the mixture to thicken. I wonder if I did something wrong. What was the thickened consistency supposed to be like? I assume not a tradition custard? I mostly had foam
