Stuffed Roasted Yellow Peppers or Red Peppers in Tomato Sauce Recipe (2024)

Ratings

5

out of 5

424

user ratings

Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

Jeanette

Open the peppers and clean before charring the skin to remove. Saves time and you don't have to handle the peppers as much which risks tearing them.

Es

This serves 4 as a side dish. What I did for the 2 of us: I made 2 peppers (they turned out great) and realizing this wasn't anywhere close to enough for dinner I made a bunch of small and light meatballs. The peppers in the marinara were surrounded by these little meatballs. Looked nice and tasted delicious. With a salad and bread, it made for a nice winter dinner. Also, I was able to clean the peppers without making the slits.

Adarsh Khalsa

Used red rice instead of quinoa as my husband doesn't like quinoa. Also added some red chili pepper flakes to garlic and parsley to give it some zip. Came out great and will make again

Amanda

I didn’t have parsley, so I substituted frozen spinach and loved it!

sean

Way too much work, not worth it.

BB

Used quinoa. Roasted peppers till blistered but didn’t remove the skins

Bonnie Ochoa

I made this by combining Shulman’s with Heuck’s. Added fennel and onion with ground beef, oregano and a couple Italian sausages; it made 2X more than the filling required, so froze the rest (for meatloaf, a new stuffed pepper, etc). Last 15 mins took off the aluminum foil and allowed it to toast. Wasn’t necessary to peel the peppers, but did char them Big hit.

BB

Made a 2nd time with Farro. Add beans next time.Needs 30 mins to get hot.

BB

Cooked with farro. Add beans next time. Needs 30 mins to heat through.

KitchenWitchoftheWest

To simplify weeknight prep, I cut two large peppers in half from top to bottom and browned them well, flipping them over so the interior would soften, too, and did not remove the skins. The filling was a bit bland for my taste, so I added sautéed celery and fresh thyme, basil, and mint. The peppers baked on a thick layer of marinara with a bit of cheese on top. Delicious and adaptable.

gigi

Not worth the effort. The mini pepper version was much tastier

Tara

Add scrambled tofu and chopped red onions cooked in marinara sauce

HMR

I added onion, mushrooms, and soy chorizo to the filling. Still a bit bland but serviceable.

debsa

I agree it is easier to open the peppers before broiling. They don’t split if you allow them to open just enough to make the cuts. I found the cheese a little overpowering in flavor and it didn’t actually contribute to the texture. Next time will omit to allow the fresh flavors to shine. I drizzled a few tablespoons of sauce around, and on top of, the peppers prior to baking. Served with small bison meatballs. Delicious. Would be a great prep-ahead dinner party dish as it is so pretty

Alex

Very tasty! I made the mistake of using a cheap jar of store-bought marinara for this recipe. Because the marinara is really just for finishing the dish, it's totally worth using homemade, or leveling-up the pre-made option to something you know will be really delicious.

Erwan

Followed the recipe and we thought it was kind of blend. Not worth the level of effort. It's missing something, like cheese maybe. And it's lacking deep flavors. Won't make it again.

CCScotty

Pretty good, but needs more flavor. Added chick peas to quinoa and made lots of it to have to stuff peppers next time. Didn’t do the sauté, so no garlic. The cheese and sauce make it. Super healthy

Pat Lewis

TJ's has canned Greek Chickpeas with Parsley and Cumin, which adds a wonderful flavor punch.

Bridget Gibbons

Definitely lemon and red pepper flakes in the stuffing. After 10 minutes of baking the peppers in the oven, I added some marinara sauce to the baking dish along with nine TJ's meatless meatballs, recovered the dish and baked for about 20 more minutes. One less pan, added protein, absolutely yummy.

Jenn

I really enjoyed the roasted pepper aspect of this but it is time consuming. I stuffed them with leftover Greek bulgar and Brussels sprouts leftover from last night and that cut down my time but the pepper prep still made this take awhile. Tasty and a convenient use of leftovers.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Stuffed Roasted Yellow Peppers or Red Peppers in Tomato Sauce Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What are the best peppers for stuffing? ›

Here's what you'll need to make these easy stuffed peppers: Red bell peppers – Red bell peppers will always be my #1 pick. If you want to try a different color, use yellow or orange peppers, as they're sweeter than their green counterparts. Black beans – Use canned, or cook your own.

What are the ingredients for stuffed peppers? ›

Do you pre-cook bell peppers before stuffing them? ›

Remove seeds and membranes; rinse. Place peppers, with tops, upright in ungreased 9x12 inch glass baking dish. Cover with plastic wrap; microwave until hot, 3 to 4 minutes--(note: do NOT cook peppers until done, you are just blanching them, 3 to 4 minutes should be plenty, depending on the size of your peppers).

What is the difference between yellow peppers and red peppers? ›

Food scientists generally agree that the red bell pepper packs the biggest punch for nerve, brain and heart health due to its heightened levels of vitamin A, potassium and folate, while the yellow pepper holds the most vitamin C.

Which color bell pepper is best for stuffing? ›

While you can use any color, for this Italian version, red bell peppers are my favorite, as their sweet flavor pairs nicely with Italian herbs and cheese. How Do You Cut Peppers for Stuffing? Start by washing and drying the peppers. Then, halve your peppers from top to bottom, cutting right down through the stems.

How do you keep stuffed peppers from falling apart? ›

Another way to pre-cook peppers for a less damp result is to roast them for a bit before stuffing. Once you've halved them and removed the seeds, lightly oil a baking sheet and place them open-side down. Let them cook on high heat for a tight ten or so minutes, then flip them over and roast for another five.

What is a fancy name for stuffed peppers? ›

The chile relleno, literally "stuffed pepper", consists of a roasted and peeled/skinned green pasilla or poblano pepper stuffed with cheese (traditionally queso fresco) and, occasionally, minced meat, covered in an egg batter, and fried.

Why do my stuffed peppers taste bland? ›

The thing about most stuffed bell pepper recipes is 3that they call for salt in the filling, not for the peppers themselves. Without salt, the peppers are flabby and bland, merely a filling case. With a sprinkle of salt, they transform into a sweet and powerfully savory part of the dish.

Do you roast peppers up or down? ›

Place peppers cut-side down on parchment paper. (Alternatively, rub a small amount of olive oil on the sheet tray.) Place pan in the oven for about 30 to 40 minutes, until the skin is blistery and charred. Don't be impatient here: If the skin isn't blistery enough, the peppers will be difficult to peel.

Can I substitute red pepper for yellow pepper? ›

Some varieties of bell pepper even appear brown, white, lavender, and dark purple, depending on their cultivar and their level of ripeness. For the most part, red, orange, and yellow bell peppers can be used interchangeably in recipes, despite their small differences in flavor.

Which color bell pepper is the healthiest? ›

Red peppers pack the most nutrition, because they've been on the vine longest. Bell peppers come in a range of colors, including red (the sweetest), orange, yellow, and green.

What are yellow peppers called? ›

Yellow chile peppers are used similarly to red chile peppers in culinary applications, and some of the most recognized yellow varieties include wax peppers, banana peppers, Santa Fe grande peppers, aji amarillo, and golden cayenne peppers.

What are the best peppers to grow for stuffing? ›

  • Anaheim Chili. Anaheim Chili Pepper Plant. ...
  • Anchio 101. Anchio 101 Pepper Plant. ...
  • Ancho Gigantea. Ancho Gigantea Pepper Plant. ...
  • Barker. Barker Pepper Plant. ...
  • Bell Boy. Bell Boy Pepper Plant. ...
  • Big Bertha. Big Bertha Pepper Plant. ...
  • Chinese Giant. Chinese Giant Bell Pepper Plant. ...
  • Chocolate Bell. Chocolate Bell Pepper Plant.

Which bell peppers have the most flavor? ›

Red bell peppers are the sweetest of the bell pepper varieties while green peppers will taste more bitter because they are in their less mature and unripe forms. For this reason, slicing and snacking on raw bell peppers may be more palatable if you choose a red bell pepper, or even a yellow or orange color variety.

What are the 4 most common bell peppers? ›

The most common colors of bell peppers are green, yellow, orange and red.

What pepper do chefs use? ›

Sourced especially for chefs, McCormick Culinary Whole Black Pepper comes from mature pepper berries, perfectly sun-dried for seven to ten days, in a whole, uniform peppercorn format to add flavor in pickling mixes, marinades and sauces.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. Nancy Dach

Last Updated:

Views: 6510

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (57 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. Nancy Dach

Birthday: 1993-08-23

Address: 569 Waelchi Ports, South Blainebury, LA 11589

Phone: +9958996486049

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Web surfing, Scuba diving, Mountaineering, Writing, Sailing, Dance, Blacksmithing

Introduction: My name is Prof. Nancy Dach, I am a lively, joyous, courageous, lovely, tender, charming, open person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.